Sunday, October 19, 2008

During our in class discussion we talked about how in the foreword of Fires in the Mirror Cornel West says that people too often see others as symbols or groups rather than people. I think it's incredible how often we dehumanize other humans. Whether it's a soldier thinking of the another soldier as "The Enemy," or it's the student walking down the hall labeling others as "The Jock" "The Geek" "A Goth." In some cases such as the one with the soldier this dehumanization is done intentionally to make it easier for us to do or think believe something. But I also think that in cases like the one with the student it is done mostly subconsciously. Like our minds need to put people in groups in order to simplify how we view others. Maybe we put people into these groups because it would be too overwhelming for us too see everyone as individual with many different traits and personalities. Maybe our minds just wouldn't be able to handle and process that much information, and so we find ways to organize the people around us into neat little groups. My question is What do we gain (if anything) by grouping people like this? what do we loose?

3 comments:

maddie hilbrant said...

Ellery, I think this is an awesome post! I think that especially at New Trier, you see labels on people. I do think that our school is better than other schools with regards to labels but the "types" are definitely there. You have the geeks, the jocks, the goths etc. I think its so sad that we label people, and its cool to open up this topic.

Abby said...

I think you make a good point with how we subconsciously label people into groups. To answer your question, I think for some people it's a gain to know what "group" you fit in and what kind of "type" of person you are. But like Maddie said, it is sad when we label. When you label a person, you're not able to see who they really are, what they're like-you're sterotyping them.

Victoria E. said...

Wow! What an amazing point you made in this post! It is such a broad thing to write and talk about but you did a really great job on this. I agree with Abby and Maddie. It is totally true that people get labelled as being something that may end up not even being true just based on their outside appearance! It is very sad that this occurs but it does and I think it is a very hard cycle to stop! I do believe however, people label other people to benefit themselves! But that if they get to know the person, they usually drop the label they had given someone because they learn who the person truly is!